June 18, 2010

AS MANIPUR BURNS AGAIN, THE CENTER CHOOSES TO REMAIN INDECISIVE

As this magazine goes for print, the inhabitants of Manipur possibly would be getting some kind of relief from the ordeal that started on 11th of April. It was on that day that the All Naga Students Association blocked the National Highway 39 (the lifeline of Manipur) in retaliation to the Manipur state government’s decision to not permit National Socialist Council of Nagaland (Isak-Muivah) leader Muviah to visit his native village in Manipur. The Manipur state government took this stance as they feared that Muviah’s visit might again instigate unrest in the region. In fact, they even turned down the request from the Center to provide adequate security to Muviah during his visit, forcing Muviah to camp at the borders of Manipur. The situation further flared up when a couple of NSCN (IM) supporters got killed in police firing. What followed after that was an indefinite blockade by NSCN (IM) supporters, which almost drove Manipur to a state of complete collapse. With rice selling at Rs. 100 a kg, petrol at Rs. 150 a litre, to a gas cylinder at Rs. 1500, prices shot up to such an extent that it was out of reach of most in Manipur. It was finally when the Prime Minister intervened, and met the Naga students, that they agreed to lift the blockade, temporarily!

Although for the time being, there would be some momentary respite for Manipur, but the problem is complex and it would require the intervention of the Center on an immediate basis. There are three key stakeholders to this problem. First, the NSCN (IM) – who since decades have been demanding a larger and extended territorial right for the state of Nagaland, which eats into the territories of Assam, Arunachal Pradesh and Manipur, much to the dislike of all the three states. The second stakeholder – the state of Manipur, which has been at the receiving end, and is determined not to allow Muviah to visit his native village for the abovementioned reasons. And the third stakeholder is the Central Government, which has been a mute spectator while the situation moved from bad to worse. In fact, the Center’s stance is nothing unexpected. Neither is it the first time that Manipur faced such a situation nor is it the first time that the Center has chosen to remain silent for such a prolonged period when a state, any state, has been suffering. Be it Telangana, Bodoland, Vidharba, Purvachal or Kashmir, the Center seems to deliberately delay, perchance to seek the maximum political mileage from the same. It has become almost a routine that prior to elections, every political party would commit to honour the demands of regional entities with respect to formation of separate states, clearly to gain maximum political mileage from the announcement and mollycoddling. Once in power, neither do they honour their commitments nor do they provide an alternate workable solution. Territorial problems are ubiquitous to India and lack of political decisiveness has a historical precedence. Kashmir has been a classic case in point where perpetual indecisiveness has not only cost the nation crores of rupees, but most importantly also thousands of lives!

Like I said earlier, every stakeholder to this current problem in Manipur has their own self centered political agenda. First, let us understand Muviah’s agenda. For that, one would have to understand why Muviah decided to time a visit to his native village right now, after so many years. The reason is quite evident. The entire existence of NSCN (IM) and Muviah is based on the creation of a greater Nagaland. And Muviah has been so far unable to negotiate an extension of the ceasefire (which was last extended in 2001) by the Center. In the absence of the ceasefire, Muviah planned this visit to appease the Nagas in Manipur – who incidentally are also the most active cadres of the NCSN. Similarly, in the absence of the ceasefire, the Manipur government also turned down the Center’s directive to provide security to Muviah during his visit, again to appease their own electorate. They could hardly imagine then, that this stance of theirs would inflict more suffering on their own people. Not that the Manipur government wants the Center to extend the ceasefire, which would virtually mean giving up to the demands of NCSN (IM). And finally, as far as the Center is concerned, not only have they been indecisive about giving the ceasefire extension, the Center has neither been capable of providing any kind of clear directives to permanently resolve the crisis.

All in all, it is politics as usual, and like always, it is the common man who is at the receiving end.

Share/Bookmark

9 comments:

Fritz Tegularius said...

Clearly the centre makes its choices. At least you haven't blamed the British. India's problems cannot be addressed until Indians fully realize they run India the British left in the last century, the last millennium. At some point India will have to own up to having destroyed what could have been a dream. If the Naga people want to have a go at determinig their own future as terrible as that may sound to a modern Indian. That's how democracy works. You had 60 years to persuade them that they were better off with you and the choices you made don't seem to have impressed them. The alternative which India seems to be edging for is rather self-destructive. If India wants to push the idea that might is right. That they have 60 thousand paramilitaries occupying Manipur now. That they are sending in another 16 companies of paramilitary thugs to open the roads into Manipur. And I don't believe that it was far too difficult to build a more efficient road network perhaps the Nagas will oblige if they are given the authority and responsibility for self determination. Oh yes my point. You mentioned Arunachal Pradesh as a possible naga stronghold. According to China Arunachal Pradesh or parts of it are sovereign Chinese soil. They have asked very politely for India to discuss how India wishes to surrender the land. And given that they can't allow a Dalai Lama to reincarnate in old Tibet not occupied by China, they will have to become more insistent as time goes on. India cannot defend itself from a first world military power. It may draw others in. But that is the alternative. Indeed I have met many Indians who tell me both that they are prepared to die to defend Manipur and the territorial integrity of India and that they have no idea where Manipur is or what its problems might be. Anyone who so lightly offers to die for a cause surely has no real belief in it. But you are right I came to mock I no longer believe Indians listen to reason or are suaded by just cause.

Pink Blossoms said...

There are some fundamental errors here - The genesis of the blockade is NOT the Govt of Manipur's prohibiting Muivah to enter Manipur but its the decision of the Govt to hold District Council elections in the hills. The Nagas, mainly, are opposed to the the council Act as it stands today and demand certain modifications and clarifications - which to be fair to them, the Govt of Manipur hasnt given them a chance to have a dialog...

Reco said...

The reasons behind the Economic blockade (It was never because of the visit of Muivah)

Following the government of Manipur's Cabinet decision to go ahead with elections to the Autonomous District Councils in Manipur hill districts in the month of May, the agitating All Naga Students' Association, Manipur (ANSAM) has declared to impose the blockade indefinitely from April 24 midnight along the two national highways leading to Manipur After thorough deliberation on the imposed Legislation (3rd Amendment) Act 2008 which threatens the very existence of the tribal endorsed to reject the 3rd Amendment Act 2008 and demand to defer enforcement of the Act and to review and nullify the 2008 Act,"Inspite of strong resentment from tribal people, the cabinet decision to go ahead with ADC election is an act of suppressing peoples right and brutalization of human rights.

zen said...

some people act, some people react while some section remain silent but it is the common people only who suffers in the end. it is them, the common people, particularly in manipur, to do something which will, at least, turn the tide away

洪筱婷 said...

人因夢想而偉大,要堅持自己的理想哦......................................................................

siddhant said...

Hey everyone,if you want an Indian to avail an opera internship,please visit my video post and post your comments as it is your votes that count

http://my.opera.com/iamsid/blog/am-i-the-one

If you are passionate about India ,please let an Indian win this Internship

Atif said...

What a post! I wish I could post like you. Nice gud job! :).

Hi! frndz plzz must visit here

computer solution visit here okkay!
thnk U!

www.Lmobile10.blogspot.com

ronwthlv said...

Too long a comment... deserves to be at your dashboard.@Fritz Tegularius

Tharik Sham : Mobile Tricks said...

nice post!!

pcmobileshelper.blogspot.com
Pc Mobile Help and Mobile Tricks


mobiletrickspc.co.cc
Mobile-Tricks Home

" This blog is managed by The Sunday Indian. We heartily welcome comments on the articles.. However TSI will delete all those comments which are personal in nature and have the usage of unparliamentary language. "